Peer Review Process

Publication in Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen dan Bisnis (JIMB) depends solely on the scientific quality, originality, and relevance of the manuscript, as judged by the editors and independent peer reviewers. JIMB uses double-blind peer review: the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the process.

Review Process

Figure. The peer review process of JIMB.

  1. Initial check. The editorial office checks that the manuscript follows the journal template and Submission Guidelines, and screens it for similarity under the Plagiarism Screening Policy. Incomplete manuscripts are returned to the authors.
  2. Editorial assessment. The editor assesses whether the manuscript fits the Aims and Scope and meets minimum standards of originality and scientific rigor. Manuscripts that do not are rejected without external review (desk rejection).
  3. Peer review. Manuscripts that pass the editorial assessment are sent to at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the subject. Reviewers have no conflict of interest with the authors, as set out in the Conflict of Interest Policy. When the reviewers' recommendations differ significantly, the editor may invite an additional reviewer.
  4. Editorial decision. Based on the review reports, the editor decides to accept the manuscript, request minor or major revisions, or reject it. The editor may consult members of the Editorial Board.
  5. Revision. Authors revise the manuscript and submit a point-by-point response to every reviewer comment. Revised manuscripts may be sent back to the reviewers for a further round of review.
  6. Acceptance and publication. Accepted manuscripts go through copyediting, layout, and proofreading by the authors before publication in the next available issue.

What Reviewers Evaluate

Reviewers are asked to assess whether the manuscript:

  • is original, with clearly stated objectives and research gap;
  • is methodologically sound;
  • presents results clearly, and whether the results support the conclusions;
  • cites relevant and recent literature correctly;
  • follows appropriate ethical standards.

Reviewers are not expected to copyedit manuscripts. Language editing is the authors' responsibility. Detailed instructions are given in the Reviewer Guidelines.

Decisions and Appeals

The editor is responsible for the final decision on every manuscript. Authors who believe a decision was based on a factual error may appeal once, as described in the Complaints & Appeals Policy. Manuscripts submitted by members of the editorial team are handled by another editor and follow the same review process.

Becoming a Reviewer

JIMB gratefully acknowledges the work of its reviewers. Reviewing offers early insight into new research in your field, and reviewers receive a certificate of appreciation and are listed on the Reviewers page. Researchers who would like to join the reviewer team can apply through the reviewer application form.