Conflict of Interest Policy

A conflict of interest exists when financial, professional, or personal relationships could influence, or appear to influence, a person's judgment about a manuscript. JIMB requires every author, reviewer, and editor to declare such interests so that decisions remain fair and transparent.

Authors must state any competing interests and all sources of funding in a "Declaration of Competing Interest" section at the end of the manuscript. If there are none, authors write: "The authors declare no competing interests."

Reviewers must decline an invitation, or inform the editor, if they:

  • work at the same institution as any of the authors;
  • have co-authored, collaborated, or had a supervisory relationship with any author in the past three years;
  • have a financial or personal interest in the outcome of the work;
  • believe they cannot judge the manuscript objectively for any other reason.

Editors do not handle manuscripts in which they have a conflict of interest. Such manuscripts are assigned to another member of the editorial board.

Manuscripts from editors and the publisher's institution. Manuscripts submitted by members of the editorial team are handled entirely by another editor, and the author-editor has no access to the review records. Manuscripts by authors from Universitas Pendidikan Nasional are always reviewed by reviewers from other institutions. These manuscripts follow the same double-blind review and acceptance standards as all other submissions.

Undeclared conflicts discovered after publication are handled under the journal's Publication Ethics and Corrections policies.