Complaints & Appeals Policy

JIMB welcomes complaints and appeals as a way to improve its editorial process. Every complaint or appeal is handled confidentially, fairly, and by someone who was not involved in the original decision.

Appeals against editorial decisions. Authors who believe a rejection was based on a factual error or a misunderstanding of the manuscript may appeal once.

  1. Send the appeal to the Editor-in-Chief within 30 days of the decision, through the Contact page. Include the manuscript ID and a point-by-point explanation of why the decision should be reconsidered.
  2. The appeal is assessed by an editor who did not handle the manuscript. This editor may consult the original reviewers or invite an additional reviewer.
  3. The outcome is communicated to the authors with the reasons. The decision on an appeal is final.

Disagreement with a reviewer's opinion alone is not grounds for an appeal. Manuscripts under appeal must not be submitted to another journal until the appeal is concluded.

Complaints. Authors, reviewers, readers, and others may complain about the journal's processes, delays, or the conduct of editors or reviewers. Complaints are acknowledged within 7 working days, and JIMB aims to resolve them within 30 days. Complaints about an editor are handled by the Editor-in-Chief, and complaints about the Editor-in-Chief by the Managing Editor.

Allegations of misconduct. Allegations of plagiarism, data manipulation, authorship disputes, or other misconduct are investigated following COPE flowcharts. Outcomes may include a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction under the journal's Corrections & Retractions Policy.