Post-Publication Discussion, Complaints and Appeals

Post-Publication Discussion, Complaints and Appeals

Jurnal Analisis Hukum (JAH) recognizes that scholarly discussion continues after publication. The journal welcomes constructive critique and debate on published articles as part of the academic process.

1. Comments and Responses on Published Articles

Readers may submit comments, critiques, or responses to articles published in JAH through the following channels:

  • Letter to the Editor / Commentary: A short written response (maximum [1,500] words) may be sent to the editorial office through the contact page or by email at [email jurnal]. The letter must refer to the specific article (title and DOI), be scholarly in tone, and be supported by arguments and references.
  • Review process: Letters are assessed by the editors and, where necessary, by reviewers. If accepted, the authors of the original article are invited to submit a reply, and both texts may be published together in a subsequent issue.

Comments that are defamatory, personal, or irrelevant to the content of the article will not be considered.

2. Reporting Errors

Readers who find factual errors, inaccurate citations, or other problems in a published article are encouraged to notify the editorial office. Such reports are handled under the Correction and Retraction Policy.

3. Complaints

Complaints regarding the journal's editorial process, decisions, or conduct may be sent to the Editor-in-Chief. The complaint should clearly describe the issue and include the relevant submission ID or article details. The editorial office will acknowledge the complaint within [7] working days and aim to provide a response within [30] days. Complaints concerning the Editor-in-Chief will be handled by [the Managing Editor / the publisher, Universitas Pendidikan Nasional].

4. Appeals Against Editorial Decisions

Authors who believe that their manuscript was rejected on the basis of a factual error or misunderstanding may submit one appeal per manuscript. The appeal must:

  • Be submitted within [30] days of the decision;
  • Provide a detailed, point-by-point explanation of why the decision should be reconsidered;
  • Respond specifically to the reviewers' and editors' comments.

Appeals are assessed by an editor who was not involved in the original decision, who may consult additional reviewers. The outcome of the appeal is final. The manuscript must not be submitted to another journal while the appeal is under consideration.