Social Identities and Rivalries among Kaizer Chiefs and Orlando Pirates Online Football Fans in YouTube Podcasts

Admire Lesenga Maluleke; Mopailo Thomas Thatelo

doi:10.38043/commusty.v5i1.7801

Authors

Admire Lesenga Maluleke University of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa https://orcid.org/0009-0007-5661-2398
Mopailo Thomas Thatelo University of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5796-9611

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.38043/commusty.v5i1.7801

Keywords:

convergence culture, football, participatory culture, podcast, social media, YouTube, thematic critical analysis

Abstract

The paper examines how Kaizer Chiefs and Orlando Pirates online fans are involved in participatory cultural agency through YouTube podcasts production and commentary in South Africa. Drawing on participatory culture framework integrated within a thematic critical analysis approach, the study analyses ten purposively selected YouTube podcast episodes from South African football fan channels active between January 2023 and March 2026. The paper adopts a qualitative interpretivist design. Study findings reveal that fans are not passive consumers of media, however, they are active cultural producers who creates, circulate and contest meaning through online podcast discourse. Through the thematic critical analysis, six themes emerged from data, namely: fan rivalry and identity, loyalty, love of the club, community and social cohesion, passion, and criticism of club management and performance. These themes collectively demonstrates that South African football fans deploy podcast platforms as spaces of participatory agency. They challenge mainstream sports media narratives, assert multilingual cultural identities and build local communities of practice. This paper address a significant research gap in African sports media research by centering South African football fandom in digital media scholarship.

Author Biographies

Admire Lesenga Maluleke, University of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa

Department of Communication Science, University of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa

Mopailo Thomas Thatelo, University of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa

Department of Communication Science, University of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa

References

Aichner, T., (2019). “Company-generated content on social networking sites.” Journal of Business Research, 98, pp.280-292.

Alegi, P. & Timbs, R., (2019). “African football and social media: The boundaries of fan community.” Soccer & Society, 20(5), pp.712-726.

Berg, J.,(2021). “Sports media and digital transformation: Audience engagement in the streaming era.” Media, Culture & Society, 43(2), pp.213-229.

Bosch, T.,( 2022). “Youth, digital media, and culture in South Africa: Practising belonging in the digital age.” Journal of African Cultural Studies, 34(3), pp.267-283.

Braun, V. & Clarke, V.,(2022). “Thematic analysis: A practical guide.” London: Sage Publications.

Breen, A. & Hoey, T., (2022). “Football and digital media: The transformation of the sports broadcasting landscape.” International Journal of Sport Communication, 15(1), pp.42-59.

Carragher, J. (2020). “The Greatest Games: The ultimate book for football fans inspired by the #1 podcast.” London: Random House

Choto, P., Chiweshe, M.K. & Muparamoto, N., (2019). “Soccer rivalries in Africa: A sociological analysis of Zimbabwean football”. Soccer & Society, 20(4), pp.600-615.

Curry, L.A., (2020). “Qualitative and mixed methods in sport and exercise research.” London: Routledge.

Deuze, M., (2021). “Media Life.” Cambridge: Polity Press.

Finger, T., Amann, J., Biel, J., Niemann, A., & Reinke, V. (2023). “Researching football, identity and cohesion in Europe”. Sports Law, Policy & Diplomacy Journal, 1(1), 131-157.

Fraser, N., 1990. “Rethinking the public sphere: A contribution to the critique of actually existing democracy.” Social Text, 25/26, pp.56-80.

Granberg, E. & Lofblad, M., (2023). “Football podcasts and brand loyalty: A study of American football podcast consumers”. Journal of Sports Media, 18 (1), pp.53-71.

Haslam, S.A., Boen, F. & Fransen, K., (2020). Social identity theory and the social psychology of sport. In: R.J. Schinke & K. McGannon, eds. “The psychology of sub-culture in sport and physical activity”. London: Routledge, pp.31-47.

Hirshon, J., (2020). “Social identity and group dynamics in football fandom”. International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 18(4), pp.456-472.

Jacobson, J., (2021). “The podcasting handbook: Sports, culture, and digital media.” New York: Routledge.

Jenkins, H., (1992). “Textual Poachers: Television Fans and Participatory Culture.” New York: Routledge.

Jenkins, H., Ford, S. & Green, J., (2013). “Spreadable Media: Creating Value and Meaning in a Networked Culture.” New York: New York University Press.

Kucharska, W., Confente, I. & Brunetti, F., (2020). “The loyalty of football fans: How much does team brand reputation count?” Journal of Product and Brand Management, 30(3), pp.441-456.

Kuhn, G., (2019). “Soccer vs. the state: Tackling football and radical politics.” Oakland: PM Press.

Louis, J., (2023). “COVID-19 and the football industry: Digital media strategies for fan engagement during the pandemic.” Sport Management Review, 26(2), pp.201-218.

Mahmuodin, A., Sadeghi-Boroujerdi, S., & J Baker, B. (2024). “Identify national football team fans’ coping strategies against the team identity threat.” Applied Research of Sport Management, 13(1), 57-74.

Mattesi, A., (2019). “Sports media transitions: From traditional broadcasting to digital platforms.” Journal of Sport and Social Issues, 43(3), pp.189-207.

McCombs, M. E., & Shaw, D. L. (1972). “The agenda-setting function of mass media”. Public Opinion Quarterly, 36(2), 176–187

Moustakas, L. (2022). “Sport for social cohesion: Transferring from the pitch to the community?” Social Sciences, 11(11), 513.

Ncube, L., Mare, A. & Muzondo, N., (2023). “Football and identity politics in Southern Africa: The Soweto Derby in historical context.” African Identities, 21(1), pp.89-107.

Newson, M., Buhrmester, M., & Whitehouse, H. (2023). “United in defeat: Shared suffering and group bonding among football fans.” Managing Sport and Leisure, 28(2), 164-181.

Ntuli, P. & Lesame, Z., (2022). “Digital media adoption in South African sports broadcasting: Emerging trends and implications.” Communicatio: South African Journal for Communication Theory and Research, 48(2), pp.1-20.

Popp, B., Horbel, C., & Germelmann, C.C. (2018). “Social-media-based antibrand communities opposing sport-team sponsors: Insights from two prototypical communities.” International Journal of Sport Communication, 11 (3), 339-368.

Priya, A., (2021). “Case study methodology of qualitative research: Key attributes and navigating the conundrums in its application.” Sociological Bulletin, 70 (1),pp.94-110.

Rahman, M. M., Rosenberger III, P. J., Yun, J. H., de Oliveira, M. J., & Köcher, S. (2024). “Keeping the ball rolling: using the SOR framework to investigate the determinants of football fan loyalty.” Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics, 36 (1), 122-147.

Rahmiyati, R., Dewi, M.P. & Eliza, E., (2021). “Student’s perception on the use of podcast in teaching listening.” Journal of English Language Pedagogy, 6(1), pp.23-32.

Randles, M., (2021) “Web 2.0 and participatory culture: New forms of social interaction.” Journal of Web Communication, 12(3), pp.88-105.

Raw, K., Sherry, E. & Rowe, K., (2022). “Sport for social cohesion: Exploring aims and complexities.” Sport Management Review, 25(3), pp.454-475.

Ricatti, F. & Klugman, M., (2020). “Football is life: The loves and madness of Roma tifosi.” Continuum, 34(5), pp.790-805.

Ronconi, J.P., (2022). “Divided for good: Football rivalries and social cohesion in Latin America.” Soccer & Society, 23(2), pp.145-162.

Santos, T. O., Correia, A., Biscaia, R., & Pegoraro, A. (2019). “Examining fan engagement through social networking sites”. International Journal of Sports Marketing and Sponsorship, 20 (1), 163-183.

Scauso, M.S., (2020). “Interpretivism: Definitions, trends, and emerging paths.” Oxford Research Encyclopedia of International Studies. [online] Available at: https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190846626.013.481 [Accessed 1 January 2026].

Sengul, K., (2019). “Critical discourse analysis in political communication research.” Communication Research and Practice, 5(4), pp.376-392.

Shernell, P., (2021). “The impact of digital media platforms on sport reporting and audience engagement: A case study of Twitter in South Africa.” University of Johannesburg, pp.1-14.

Sullivan, J.L., (2019). “The platforms of podcasting: Past and present.” Social Media + Society, 5(4).

Tajfel, H.& Turner, J.C., (1986). “The social identity theory of intergroup behaviour.” In: S. Worchel & W.G. Austin, eds. Psychology of Intergroup Relations. Chicago: Nelson-Hall, pp.7-24.

Terry, G. & Hayfield, N., (2020). “Reflexive thematic analysis.” In: G. Harper, ed. Handbook of qualitative research in education. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp.430-441.

Theocharis, Y. & Jungherr, A., (2021). “Computational social science and the study of political communication.” Political Communication, 38(1-2), pp.1-22.

Thomas, E.P., (2020). “Sports podcast consumption: A qualitative media content analysis.” Liberty University.

Tucker, L., (2020). “Football capital: What is it and why is it important?” Managing Sport and Leisure, 25(1-2), pp.52-63.

Tyler, B.D., Cobbs, J. & Xantos, Y.K., (2019). “The roots of rivalry: Elements and core characteristics of sport rivalry.” Champaign: IGI Global, pp.1-37.

Wakefield, K., (2016). “Using fan passion to predict attendance, media consumption, and social media behaviours.” Journal of Sport Management, 30 (3), pp.229-247.

Winand, M., Schneiders, C., Merten, S., & Marlier, M. (2021). “Sports fans and innovation: An analysis of football fans’ satisfaction with video assistant refereeing through social identity and argumentative theories.” Journal of Business Research, 136, 99-109.